| Platinum | Papa Frank's |
| Gold | Razzo's |
| Silver | Bella Milano |
| Bronze | Sam's Italian Pizza |
| Top Pick | Antonio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Fulgenzi's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Gallina Pizza |
| Top Pick | La Piazza Cucina Italiana |
| Top Pick | Mariah's Steakhouse & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Sapori Pizzaria and Italian Store |