| Platinum | Krekel's Custard |
| Gold | Anvil & Forge |
| Silver | Portillo's Hot Dogs |
| Bronze | Greenie's Grill |
| Top Pick | Eagle Golf and Grill |
| Top Pick | Engrained Brewing Company |
| Top Pick | Fairlane Diner |
| Top Pick | Gyros Stop |
| Top Pick | Nesty's Burger Joint Rochester |
| Top Pick | Sunrise Cafe |