| Platinum | Fluorescent Reefs |
| Gold | Pet Supplies Plus |
| Silver | Tails to Remember |
| Bronze | Wild Birds Unlimited |
| Top Pick | 3 Cats & A Corgi |
| Top Pick | Capitol Illini Veterinary Services |
| Top Pick | Pampered Pet Center, |
| Top Pick | PetSmart |
| Top Pick | Springfield West Farm & Home Supply |
| Top Pick | Treasures for Tails |