| Platinum | Bernie & Betty's Pizza |
| Gold | Home Plate Bar & Grill |
| Silver | Dillon's Pizza |
| Silver | Riccos Pizza |
| Bronze | Antonio's Pizza |
| Bronze | Coz's Pizza & Pub |
| Top Pick | La Piazza Cucina Italiana |
| Top Pick | Monical Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sams Too |
| Top Pick | Sapori Pizzaria and Italian Store |
| Nancy's Pizza |