| Platinum | Taielua's Table |
| Gold | Emerald's Eats |
| Silver | Poes Catering |
| Bronze | Magro's Made With Love Catering |
| Top Pick | Arena Food Service |
| Top Pick | Feeding Springfield One Lasagna At a Time |
| Top Pick | Fulgenzi's Catering |
| Top Pick | Hickory River Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Nelson's Catering |
| Top Pick | Whimsy Tea Company |